ARBITRUM CULTURE COUNCIL
NON-CONSTITUTIONAL
This proposal is the culmination of many conversations concerning the state of play on Arbitrum. From grass root degens to Arbitrum delegates, we have spent time discussing the best ways to move forward concerning the growth of memes on Arbitrum. We understand that many are hesitant to accept memes on Arbitrum, and ask that you read this proposal with an open mind. Viewing memes as exclusively devices for speculation misses the bigger picture.
Abstract
It is undeniable at this stage that speculation is the primary vector for attracting attention to blockchain ecosystems, overcoming the inertia holding new participants back from learning about and taking steps toward actively utilising these novel technologies.
With uncertain regulatory conditions weighing on the investment thesis for established infrastructure, and the majority of institutional funding raised towards “earliest stage” projects, the speculative meta has shied away from utility and looked towards participation in memecoin ecosystems.The space is dominated with enthusiasm for memes, which provide downstream adoption across the native chain infrastructure, boosting metrics, including revenues, and fostering ecosystem-wide growth.
For these reasons we suggest that the Arbitrum DAO creates a culture council to:
Motivation
All past crypto cycles have been catalysed by a speculation driven attention flywheel, and memecoin ecosystems manifest exactly these conditions. It is no secret that Solana and Base have gained lots of traction across these past few months on this basis, with memes having played a paramount role in their meteoric growth
The memecoin ecosystem native to Solana, warming up for some time prior, hit a fever pitch in the first week of December around the time of the Jito airdrop as substantial capital was injected into the hitherto beaten down blockchain. Many reading this will have remembered bridging over at this time, if they had yet to do so, as finally there was fun to be had on-chain again outside of farming incentives after a deep and brutal bear market. Subsequently, memecoining began to be adopted as a legitimate use case for the Solana blockchain, with support from all sides of the community. As of December 7th, the day of the Jito airdrop, the Solana ecosystem enjoyed 1.9m monthly active users and supported 700m USD in total value locked. Memecoining remains overwhelmingly the primary use case for the Solana blockchain today, and this activity, largely on its own, has catalysed its growth to 17.5m monthly active users and in excess of 5 billion in ecosystem-wide TVL.
Solana Network user growth - ~15,000 to ~750,000 daily active
Similarly, memecoining has accelerated the growth of the Base ecosystem, where a single meme represents ~25% of the natively minted value and ~17% of the total value on the chain. In the days prior to EIP-4844 on March 13th, the two largest memes on Base (Toshi and Brett) surpassed the 100m MC barrier, resulting in a subsequent surge of memecoining on Base. Throughout, monthly active users has risen from 1.3m to 11.3m today, with TVL rising from approximately 700m to over 1.6 billion.
Base Network user growth - ~7000 to ~190,000 daily active
We have developed a Dune dashboard which tags leading meme price events on Solana and Base as compared to network volume, users, transaction counts and fees generated for ease of reference. For this dataset, user numbers are calculated based on dex activity.
Throughout this same time period following the launch of EIP-4844, in contradiction to enthusiastic posts regarding growth in TVL, Arbitrum TVL has simply stagnated, ranging from 3.2b to 3.1b. Additionally, although monthly active users have reportedly grown from 2.6m to 5.7m over the timeframe, comparing transactions and makers on Base and Solana with Arbitrum tells another story. Transaction counts average in the tens of thousands or higher across both Base and Solana on the top coins for any particular day, with maker counts in the thousands. Arbitrum’s however, are orders of magnitude lower. Typically Arbitrum enjoys transaction counts on top pairs in the triple digits, with makers in the double or even single digits. Where are all the users on Arbitrum?
Arbitrum Network User stagnation - ~15,000 to ~8,000 daily active
In any case, all of us have observed how Solana and Base lead overwhelmingly in attention and discourse across crypto native platforms, and this is borne out as generalisable when looking at Google trends which show searches for Arbitrum as compared to Solana have flatlined, resting at single digit percentages of relative interest.
As well noted by many, the nascent memecoin ecosystem on Arbitrum has already showcased its potential for positive impact on the broader Arbitrum ecosystem even prior to any form of support from the DAO. Note the outsized impact on daily active users of the micro meme season led by Boop in March of this year, which was able to catalyse as much dex activity as the ARB airdrop itself. Moreover, weekly update posts from the official Arbitrum account with the adoption of the Boop logo have received markedly outsized engagement metrics in comparison to the same posts previously, which radically improves the potential reach and subsequent impact of such information campaigns across the platform. Arbinaut Weekly 51 has received 117k views to date, and Arbinaut Weekly 49 has received 256k views to date, while the Arbinaut Weekly posts which don’t feature a meme community have each averaged approximately 30k views over the last 3 months.
The April Fool’s post with many Arbitrum memes at a poker table is one of the single most viewed posts on the official twitter account, competing with the announcement later in April that BoLD was going live on testnet, a development at the forefront of innovation and of industry-wide significance. There is no denying that memes are loci for attention and engagement.
Speculative investment into an ecosystem naturally manifests the motivation to publicly support that host ecosystem in its goals and ideals.If we actually want to see a trustless, permissionless internet, we need the chains building that future to actively meet the public where they are, and take advantage of available mechanisms for attention to support bringing these ideals to fruition.
Toward these ends, we can further the latent partnership established between Arbitrum and Robinhood to everyone's benefit by meeting the market demand of Robinhood traders for highly speculative, socially engaging, memetic plays. We have an ideal opportunity not just to tell but to actually show this highly engaged and engaging investment community the benefits of permissionless markets, at a time when they are collectively yearning for structural fairness in the wake of alleged manipulations by traditional market incumbents against their interests.
Further, as an example of how readily memes could potentially benefit the broader DeFi ecosystem on Arbitrum, we note at the time of writing that Bonk and Wif each have open interest exceeding 3m notional on the top five Solana perps protocol Drift. Each of these memes see equivalent open interest to ARB on Arbitrum’s leading perp dex.
We, the Arbitrum community, have every motivation to employ a small portion of our massive warchest to court attention for our industry-leading ecosystem, just like everyone else. In order to onboard the next billion users, we need to be willing to meet the market where the demand exists.
Let’s work together to make Arbitrum great again.
Rationale
The establishment of a culture council is a suitable method to provide DAO support to this crucial sub-component of our industry which remains as-yet nascent on Arbitrum. We, the Arbitrum community, need a small group of dedicated community members to source and provide the DAO with information concerning the efficacy of funding and support for memes as a vector for ecosystem growth.
One of the most impressive emergent features of the Arbitrum ecosystem has been the deep cooperation and collaboration between DeFi protocols, we believe that this Arbitrum spirit could also be effectively fostered between meme communities, and between meme communities and the broader Arbitrum ecosystem. This would be encapsulated in a new narrative: MemeFi.
With proper incentivisation, an abundance of exceptional DeFi and SocialFi infrastructure already built on Arbitrum could be effectively leveraged as the best-in-class memecoin and community-building tooling in the industry. Such a collaborative effort could facilitate onboarding, contract development, competitive pre-sales, liquidity provision, collateralisation and socials, using existing infrastructure, while accelerating on-chain adoption and supporting Arbitrum native builders all at once.
We would like to provide small grants to existing DeFi to further encourage meme integration, and we would like to provide incentives to use this memeFi infrastructure. This would address all our attention and Arbitrum user growth goals whilst also supporting the existing DeFi ecosystem.
We anticipate that this proposal on its own will bring a lot of activity back to Arbitrum; if accepted this will be a green light to many that the Arbitrum DAO is interested in bringing in more new users.The community is in a broad chorus of agreement that this is exactly the sort of action we need to propel Arbitrum towards the growth goals it deserves to achieve, so, shall we begin?
Specifications
We propose to establish a culture council composed of 5 members elected from the Arbitrum community by DAO vote for a 6 month term subsequent to the approval of this proposal. We propose the council operate and be funded on a 6 month cycle, offering frequent opportunity for assessment of efficacy by the DAO and modification of the programme as necessary. We envision a roadmap for council objectives consistent of two stages:
Stage 1 - Immediate Term
Stage 2 - Long Term
Stage 1 initiatives plus:
Establish funding for grants awardable for integration of Arbitrum native memes into existing DeFi and the cross-integration of MemeFi infrastructure towards an interoperable ecosystem of dapps
Establish funding for grants for the development and integration of memeFi infrastructure into a communal front-end
Establish funding for expanded liquidity support in ARB for memeFi
Ensure the ARB token becomes integral to the resulting Arbitrum native meme ecosystem, providing utility to the ARB token and locking liquidity
Develop relationships with market makers to support the acceleration of a trial run of memes to showcase potential
As the groundwork progresses, we will return with proposals to engage each of stages 2 and 3
*THIS PROPOSAL SEEKS APPROVAL ONLY FOR IMMEDIATE TERM OBJECTIVES
Creation of a Culture Council
a) Create a culture council composed of three (3) members
b) Establish a multisig to hold funding
Goals of the Council
The council explicitly needs to work towards these goals and all members are to be held to contract to fulfill these duties:
Election Process
Applicants must be willing to fully dox to the DAO in order to be approved for election
Accountability
A vote of no confidence in individual members or the entire council from the DAO should be stipulated to return the relevant members places for early re-election for the remainder of the current term, or dissolve the programme entirely
Key Performance Indicators
The council will look for specific metrics to ensure the efficiency of its efforts in growing onchain activity. We believe that these KPIs should be evaluated during the council’s first term in order to get a better gauge of what our target metrics should be. The data scientist of the first council will determine these KPIs. We believe that KPIs should be determined down the road because many of these metrics are easily faked or inflated by unrelated activity. We would like to build out a dashboard that is specific and able to filter for the data that the council influences.
Example KPIs:
These examples are data points that are easily measurable with certainty. Any other metric such as transaction count or amount of deployments is easily faked due to the nature of Arbitrum’s cheap fees to transact and deploy.
Allocation Breakdown and Limits
Funding total of $200,000 for per 6 month cycle
Overall Cost - Stage 1 - immediate term
Total cost: $266,000 USD worth of $ARB
*THIS PROPOSAL SEEKS APPROVAL AND FUNDING ONLY FOR IMMEDIATE TERM OPERATIONS OUTLINED
ARBITRUM CULTURE COUNCIL
NON-CONSTITUTIONAL
This proposal is the culmination of many conversations concerning the state of play on Arbitrum. From grass root degens to Arbitrum delegates, we have spent time discussing the best ways to move forward concerning the growth of memes on Arbitrum. We understand that many are hesitant to accept memes on Arbitrum, and ask that you read this proposal with an open mind. Viewing memes as exclusively devices for speculation misses the bigger picture.
Abstract
It is undeniable at this stage that speculation is the primary vector for attracting attention to blockchain ecosystems, overcoming the inertia holding new participants back from learning about and taking steps toward actively utilising these novel technologies.
With uncertain regulatory conditions weighing on the investment thesis for established infrastructure, and the majority of institutional funding raised towards “earliest stage” projects, the speculative meta has shied away from utility and looked towards participation in memecoin ecosystems.The space is dominated with enthusiasm for memes, which provide downstream adoption across the native chain infrastructure, boosting metrics, including revenues, and fostering ecosystem-wide growth.
For these reasons we suggest that the Arbitrum DAO creates a culture council to:
Motivation
All past crypto cycles have been catalysed by a speculation driven attention flywheel, and memecoin ecosystems manifest exactly these conditions. It is no secret that Solana and Base have gained lots of traction across these past few months on this basis, with memes having played a paramount role in their meteoric growth
The memecoin ecosystem native to Solana, warming up for some time prior, hit a fever pitch in the first week of December around the time of the Jito airdrop as substantial capital was injected into the hitherto beaten down blockchain. Many reading this will have remembered bridging over at this time, if they had yet to do so, as finally there was fun to be had on-chain again outside of farming incentives after a deep and brutal bear market. Subsequently, memecoining began to be adopted as a legitimate use case for the Solana blockchain, with support from all sides of the community. As of December 7th, the day of the Jito airdrop, the Solana ecosystem enjoyed 1.9m monthly active users and supported 700m USD in total value locked. Memecoining remains overwhelmingly the primary use case for the Solana blockchain today, and this activity, largely on its own, has catalysed its growth to 17.5m monthly active users and in excess of 5 billion in ecosystem-wide TVL.
Solana Network user growth - ~15,000 to ~750,000 daily active
Similarly, memecoining has accelerated the growth of the Base ecosystem, where a single meme represents ~25% of the natively minted value and ~17% of the total value on the chain. In the days prior to EIP-4844 on March 13th, the two largest memes on Base (Toshi and Brett) surpassed the 100m MC barrier, resulting in a subsequent surge of memecoining on Base. Throughout, monthly active users has risen from 1.3m to 11.3m today, with TVL rising from approximately 700m to over 1.6 billion.
Base Network user growth - ~7000 to ~190,000 daily active
We have developed a Dune dashboard which tags leading meme price events on Solana and Base as compared to network volume, users, transaction counts and fees generated for ease of reference. For this dataset, user numbers are calculated based on dex activity.
Throughout this same time period following the launch of EIP-4844, in contradiction to enthusiastic posts regarding growth in TVL, Arbitrum TVL has simply stagnated, ranging from 3.2b to 3.1b. Additionally, although monthly active users have reportedly grown from 2.6m to 5.7m over the timeframe, comparing transactions and makers on Base and Solana with Arbitrum tells another story. Transaction counts average in the tens of thousands or higher across both Base and Solana on the top coins for any particular day, with maker counts in the thousands. Arbitrum’s however, are orders of magnitude lower. Typically Arbitrum enjoys transaction counts on top pairs in the triple digits, with makers in the double or even single digits. Where are all the users on Arbitrum?
Arbitrum Network User stagnation - ~15,000 to ~8,000 daily active
In any case, all of us have observed how Solana and Base lead overwhelmingly in attention and discourse across crypto native platforms, and this is borne out as generalisable when looking at Google trends which show searches for Arbitrum as compared to Solana have flatlined, resting at single digit percentages of relative interest.
As well noted by many, the nascent memecoin ecosystem on Arbitrum has already showcased its potential for positive impact on the broader Arbitrum ecosystem even prior to any form of support from the DAO. Note the outsized impact on daily active users of the micro meme season led by Boop in March of this year, which was able to catalyse as much dex activity as the ARB airdrop itself. Moreover, weekly update posts from the official Arbitrum account with the adoption of the Boop logo have received markedly outsized engagement metrics in comparison to the same posts previously, which radically improves the potential reach and subsequent impact of such information campaigns across the platform. Arbinaut Weekly 51 has received 117k views to date, and Arbinaut Weekly 49 has received 256k views to date, while the Arbinaut Weekly posts which don’t feature a meme community have each averaged approximately 30k views over the last 3 months.
The April Fool’s post with many Arbitrum memes at a poker table is one of the single most viewed posts on the official twitter account, competing with the announcement later in April that BoLD was going live on testnet, a development at the forefront of innovation and of industry-wide significance. There is no denying that memes are loci for attention and engagement.
Speculative investment into an ecosystem naturally manifests the motivation to publicly support that host ecosystem in its goals and ideals.If we actually want to see a trustless, permissionless internet, we need the chains building that future to actively meet the public where they are, and take advantage of available mechanisms for attention to support bringing these ideals to fruition.
Toward these ends, we can further the latent partnership established between Arbitrum and Robinhood to everyone's benefit by meeting the market demand of Robinhood traders for highly speculative, socially engaging, memetic plays. We have an ideal opportunity not just to tell but to actually show this highly engaged and engaging investment community the benefits of permissionless markets, at a time when they are collectively yearning for structural fairness in the wake of alleged manipulations by traditional market incumbents against their interests.
Further, as an example of how readily memes could potentially benefit the broader DeFi ecosystem on Arbitrum, we note at the time of writing that Bonk and Wif each have open interest exceeding 3m notional on the top five Solana perps protocol Drift. Each of these memes see equivalent open interest to ARB on Arbitrum’s leading perp dex.
We, the Arbitrum community, have every motivation to employ a small portion of our massive warchest to court attention for our industry-leading ecosystem, just like everyone else. In order to onboard the next billion users, we need to be willing to meet the market where the demand exists.
Let’s work together to make Arbitrum great again.
Rationale
The establishment of a culture council is a suitable method to provide DAO support to this crucial sub-component of our industry which remains as-yet nascent on Arbitrum. We, the Arbitrum community, need a small group of dedicated community members to source and provide the DAO with information concerning the efficacy of funding and support for memes as a vector for ecosystem growth.
One of the most impressive emergent features of the Arbitrum ecosystem has been the deep cooperation and collaboration between DeFi protocols, we believe that this Arbitrum spirit could also be effectively fostered between meme communities, and between meme communities and the broader Arbitrum ecosystem. This would be encapsulated in a new narrative: MemeFi.
With proper incentivisation, an abundance of exceptional DeFi and SocialFi infrastructure already built on Arbitrum could be effectively leveraged as the best-in-class memecoin and community-building tooling in the industry. Such a collaborative effort could facilitate onboarding, contract development, competitive pre-sales, liquidity provision, collateralisation and socials, using existing infrastructure, while accelerating on-chain adoption and supporting Arbitrum native builders all at once.
We would like to provide small grants to existing DeFi to further encourage meme integration, and we would like to provide incentives to use this memeFi infrastructure. This would address all our attention and Arbitrum user growth goals whilst also supporting the existing DeFi ecosystem.
We anticipate that this proposal on its own will bring a lot of activity back to Arbitrum; if accepted this will be a green light to many that the Arbitrum DAO is interested in bringing in more new users.The community is in a broad chorus of agreement that this is exactly the sort of action we need to propel Arbitrum towards the growth goals it deserves to achieve, so, shall we begin?
Specifications
We propose to establish a culture council composed of 5 members elected from the Arbitrum community by DAO vote for a 6 month term subsequent to the approval of this proposal. We propose the council operate and be funded on a 6 month cycle, offering frequent opportunity for assessment of efficacy by the DAO and modification of the programme as necessary. We envision a roadmap for council objectives consistent of two stages:
Stage 1 - Immediate Term
Stage 2 - Long Term
Stage 1 initiatives plus:
Establish funding for grants awardable for integration of Arbitrum native memes into existing DeFi and the cross-integration of MemeFi infrastructure towards an interoperable ecosystem of dapps
Establish funding for grants for the development and integration of memeFi infrastructure into a communal front-end
Establish funding for expanded liquidity support in ARB for memeFi
Ensure the ARB token becomes integral to the resulting Arbitrum native meme ecosystem, providing utility to the ARB token and locking liquidity
Develop relationships with market makers to support the acceleration of a trial run of memes to showcase potential
As the groundwork progresses, we will return with proposals to engage each of stages 2 and 3
*THIS PROPOSAL SEEKS APPROVAL ONLY FOR IMMEDIATE TERM OBJECTIVES
Creation of a Culture Council
a) Create a culture council composed of three (3) members
b) Establish a multisig to hold funding
Goals of the Council
The council explicitly needs to work towards these goals and all members are to be held to contract to fulfill these duties:
Election Process
Applicants must be willing to fully dox to the DAO in order to be approved for election
Accountability
A vote of no confidence in individual members or the entire council from the DAO should be stipulated to return the relevant members places for early re-election for the remainder of the current term, or dissolve the programme entirely
Key Performance Indicators
The council will look for specific metrics to ensure the efficiency of its efforts in growing onchain activity. We believe that these KPIs should be evaluated during the council’s first term in order to get a better gauge of what our target metrics should be. The data scientist of the first council will determine these KPIs. We believe that KPIs should be determined down the road because many of these metrics are easily faked or inflated by unrelated activity. We would like to build out a dashboard that is specific and able to filter for the data that the council influences.
Example KPIs:
These examples are data points that are easily measurable with certainty. Any other metric such as transaction count or amount of deployments is easily faked due to the nature of Arbitrum’s cheap fees to transact and deploy.
Allocation Breakdown and Limits
Funding total of $200,000 for per 6 month cycle
Overall Cost - Stage 1 - immediate term
Total cost: $266,000 USD worth of $ARB
*THIS PROPOSAL SEEKS APPROVAL AND FUNDING ONLY FOR IMMEDIATE TERM OPERATIONS OUTLINED
Refreshing to see a proposal coming from the community for the community. However, it's concerning that it has received little attention on the forum so far.
DAO participants please feel encouraged to share your thoughts on this proposal. Your feedback would be valuable in understanding why it hasn't gained more traction so far.
Refreshing to see a proposal coming from the community for the community. However, it's concerning that it has received little attention on the forum so far.
DAO participants please feel encouraged to share your thoughts on this proposal. Your feedback would be valuable in understanding why it hasn't gained more traction so far.
Given that L2Beats' 'Incentives Detox Proposal' is close to passing, the timing of this proposal may need reconsideration. Moving the timeline until after the end of the 'Detox' could allow governance participants and the culture council ample opportunity to discuss and refine the terms.
Exploring a case study on a grassroots incentive program led by active community members, rather than a DAO-managed high-overhead program, could yield interesting insights.
It's time for a change. I believe it would be valuable to see this proposal evolve and receive the attention it deserves within the governance.
It’s time for change.
It's time for change.
It’s time for change.
Refreshing to see a proposal coming from the community for the community. However, it's concerning that it has received little attention on the forum so far.
DAO participants please feel encouraged to share your thoughts on this proposal. Your feedback would be valuable in understanding why it hasn't gained more traction so far.
Refreshing to see a proposal coming from the community for the community. However, it's concerning that it has received little attention on the forum so far.
DAO participants please feel encouraged to share your thoughts on this proposal. Your feedback would be valuable in understanding why it hasn't gained more traction so far.
Given that L2Beats' 'Incentives Detox Proposal' is close to passing, the timing of this proposal may need reconsideration. Moving the timeline until after the end of the 'Detox' could allow governance participants and the culture council ample opportunity to discuss and refine the terms.
Exploring a case study on a grassroots incentive program led by active community members, rather than a DAO-managed high-overhead program, could yield interesting insights.
It's time for a change. I believe it would be valuable to see this proposal evolve and receive the attention it deserves within the governance.
It’s time for change.
It's time for change.
It’s time for change.
While we thank you for the thoughtful proposal, more details are needed to ensure that it benefits Arbitrum and is sustainable.
Some concerns:
While we thank you for the thoughtful proposal, more details are needed to ensure that it benefits Arbitrum and is sustainable.
Some concerns:
While we thank you for the thoughtful proposal, more details are needed to ensure that it benefits Arbitrum and is sustainable.
Some concerns:
While we thank you for the thoughtful proposal, more details are needed to ensure that it benefits Arbitrum and is sustainable.
Some concerns:
